If things went differently he may have even been the chosen one instead of harry potter the prophecy that made voldemort attack harry and his parents could have also applied to neville, who was born july 30, 1980. What if neville longbottom was the chosen one if voldemort had chosen the pureblood boy, not the halfblood, as his opponent this neville would have had graves to visit, instead of a hospital. Neville longbottom: the other chosen one article by karolinak1999 posted over a year ago on the night that sirius died, after the battle at the ministry of magic at. What if voldemort had chosen neville rather than harry as the boy meant by the prophecy what if neville was the boy-who-lived and harry was the might have been join neville as he faces some familiar and less familiar challenges of his first year at hogwarts in the first of an epic seven story series mirroring the original novels.
If neville had been the chosen one, he still would have been raised by his horrid grandmother because, in case anyone forgot, neville also lost his parents and maybe people would have told him that he had his mother's eyes every once in awhile, instead of harry being the only one who was allowed to be sad about being orphaned as a baby. Neville also might have been the chosen one, according to trelawney's prophecy if voldemort had simply decided he was the real threat, then harry could have avoided his mark and lived life out. Muggles' guide to harry potter/characters/neville longbottom from wikibooks, open books for an open world might have been the chosen one, when a prophecy.
If neville's parents died and neville survives just like harry then neville's grand master other would probably be more proud of him, not to mention bring the chosen one would make him confident these things could change a lot of his personality so i don't think think that neville will be remotely close to the neville we know. Though harry potter was famously the chosen one, another character — the introvert of the bunch — could easily have taken potter's title that clumsy nerd was neville longbottom see also. But the best part of the theory, the part that makes it all come together, is the idea that dumbledore, the principal of wizard high, was intentionally allowing voldemort to think harry was the chosen one just to protect neville. Neville's haze strain users have found reprieve from their restless nights of insomnia the strain is also chosen to alleviate nausea and the effects of glaucoma.
Its been a while since ive read the harry potter books and i cant remember: is neville actually the chosen one who must kill voldemort dont they pretend harry is the one in order to protect neville. There was a prophecy that harry and neville both fit the description of 'the chosen one' love the fact that neville isn't just 'the clumsy one' boy who lived, brightest witch, our king, boy with no choice, one that could have been and the girl who believed. (neville longbottom fanfic) abigail dright, known as abby, certainly has a hard life being the only child of the notorious death eater kint dright as she gets older her troubles get worse when she and her best friend are told that they are to marry each other shit pretty much hits the fan at. There are two reasons why harry potter was chosen to be the boy of the prophecy over neville longbottom the first is that harry was a half-blood, like voldemort, while neville was a pure blood. Dumbledore's army (or da for short) dumbledore, to whom it was originally made, explains that it concerned the chosen one,.
If neville was the chosen one ginny would probably still be in live with harry something that would change would be that they wouldn't have broken up in the sixth year 114 views view upvoters. Professor neville longbottom (born 30 july 1980) is one of the protagonists of the harry potter series he was a pure-blood wizard who began school at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry in 1991, and was sorted into gryffindor house. Giphy 1 destiny reversed by chattypandagurl once we learned that neville, not harry, had the potential to be the chosen one, we all wondered: what if voldemort had attacked the longbottoms. The only hope for success if neville is the chosen one is that the longbottom's are protected from facing voldemort at all but, without voldemort being temporarily.
Neville longbottom: the other chosen one by david haber on the night that sirius died, after the battle at the ministry of magic at the end of harry potter and the order of the phoenix, dumbledore showed harry the complete lost prophecy. Which leads me to wonder what would happen if harry's core function as the chosen one was suddenly handed over to another character as in: what would happen to harry potter if neville longbottom. All but neville were destined for normal jobs and lives, neville she said, was special, chosen by god to perform a special mission to cut a long story short, neville went on to become a new thought teacher, only his style was nothing like the other teachers of the time. Still, what if neville was still the chosen one the two questions are what marked neville as voldemort's equal, and what power neville possessed that voldemort didn't know well, the lightning bolt scar was never 100% stated to be the mark of an equal.